Ambulance Responds Too Late for Journalist at UN,
Searched at 1st Ave Gate, Another Investigation
Byline: Matthew Russell Lee of Inner City Press at
the UN: News Analysis
UNITED NATIONS, Feb. 21, updated Feb. 22 -- A journalist was taken
out of the UN by an ambulance, apparently too late, on the night on February 21.
Hans Janitschek, a correspondent for Austrian media, had recently returned to
the UN press corps, asking questions ranging from the bombing of the UN in
Algiers to a more recent February 17 death at the UN Headquarters. Janitschek
had long covered and been affiliated with the UN, and his fellow journalists
appreciated his expertise and sense of humor. He was still smiling when, at 7:10
p.m. Thursday, he fell to the floor. A co-worker, according to his written
statement which Inner City Press has seen, immediately called the UN operator on
three occasions "to report what had happened to Mr. Janitschek, however, they
could not provide any assistance." Regular New York City "911" emergency
services were not called, due to previous difficulties and delays in them
gaining access to the UN campus, which is international territory. Only after UN
Security and Safety Services were called directly did anyone appear, and even
then, with oxygen equipment that was less than functional.
According to the written account, in
which a senior UN Security official was involved, it was fully 24 minutes until
Emergency Services Technicians arrived, and by then it was too late. Another
reporter on the UN's press floor at that time states that the ambulance was held
for precious minutes at the gate from First Avenue, as for example the bottom of
its chassis was inspected with mirrors. The reporter questioned why ambulances
responding to medical emergencies are searched for so long.
Han Janitschek had spent his Thursday at
the UN asking questions. At the day's noon press briefing, he asked about
another death at the UN, four days previous, alluding to discordant reports in
the Viennese press. Spokesperson Michele Montas replied that there was no
indication of foul play. Later in the briefing, a staffer handed her a note, and
she amended her answer to say that the investigation is still underway. Video
Thursday night, the room in which Mr.
Janitschek had been was strewn with medical emergency detritus. UN Security said that, in order to
conduct an investigation, the room would have to be sealed, so that nothing
could be taken, including computer files, the UN security official said. So,
another investigation. One wonders if this investigation will also extend to why
ambulances responding to medical emergencies at the UN are searched for so long,
and the impact on this case.
Update: on Feb. 22 at the UN
briefing, Inner City Press asked:
Inner City Press:
How long did it take and what is the policy of the UN on letting emergency
medical personnel on the UN property?
Associate Spokesperson Farhan Haq: First of all, there were emergency medical
personnel on hand at the time. As I just mentioned, three UN security officers
who are qualified EMTs performed CPR on Mr. Janitschek, and there was no sign of
life at the time. A defibrillator was used to try to start his heart, to no
avail, and appropriate medical protocols were followed. The person who was with
Mr. Janitschek, Mr. Casella, your colleague, had immediately called the UN
operator, who called security, who then called the emergency responders,
including a direct call to New York hospital. The first responder was
actually a fire engine truck. They were not allowed in,
because they could not provide the level of care needed, compared to the trained
EMTs, who were there on site already, the three UN security officers. An
ambulance arrived 10 seconds later, and that ambulance and paramedics were let
in directly. Like I said, all of that was to no avail, ultimately. Mr.
Janitschek gave no sign of life throughout this process.
Inner City Press: First of all, who decides whether to let in or not to let in a
New York City fire truck? And what is the policy of the UN in terms of this?
Does it automatically allow emergency or fire personnel without [searching or
Associate Spokesperson: We have the protocol to call in emergency responders
when there is an emergency in the building, and that protocol was followed. As
far as checking vehicles that come in, that is a standard security procedure,
but that did not result in any significant delay. Like I said, the ambulance and
paramedics were let in directly.
The UN later added that [After the briefing, the Spokespersonís Office confirmed
that the ambulance was not stopped at the front gate at all.]
Editor's note: beyond that fact that several witnesses continue to describe the
searching of the ambulance, no one has rebutted or even denied the 24 minute
response time. In the UN's scripted statement at Friday's noon briefing,
highlighted above, it is said that a fire truck was denied entry. A UN security
officerafter the briefing confirmed that when FDNY vehicles come to the UN, the
policy is to not let them in unless there is / the UN is aware of a fire.
There's a problem: FDNY took over EMS ambulances some time ago, and FDNY
personnel are trained in the procedures which were needed Thursday night. So
why have a policy that includes turning away official NYC emergency responders
from the FDNY?
Watch this site.
* * *
These reports are
usually also available through
Google News and on Lexis-Nexis.
here for a
AlertNet piece by this correspondent about Uganda's Lord's Resistance Army.
for an earlier
piece about the Somali National Reconciliation Congress, and the UN's
$200,000 contribution from an undefined trust fund.
UN Office: S-453A,
UN, NY 10017 USA Tel: 212-963-1439
(and weekends): 718-716-3540
Other, earlier Inner
City Press are listed here, and
some are available in the ProQuest service, and now on Lexis-Nexis.
Copyright 2006-08 Inner City Press, Inc. To request
reprint or other permission, e-contact Editorial [at] innercitypress.com -